Portable water filter: what it removes, and what it leaves behind
We research products from makers' specs, manuals and safety agencies; we do not run hands-on tests. Links to Amazon may earn us a commission at no cost to you. How this works.
Quick answer
CDC says boiling is the best way to kill germs in water, and the next best option is to filter the water and then disinfect it. A filter with an absolute pore size of 0.3 micron or smaller removes bacteria and parasites, but not viruses. For viruses, choose a purifier such as MSR's Guardian, which lists a 0.02 micron pore size, or disinfect after filtering. No portable filter here removes chemicals, so water with fuel, toxins or other chemicals needs a different source.
What a filter does and does not remove
CDC sorts portable treatment by what it removes:
| Method | Parasites | Bacteria | Viruses |
|---|---|---|---|
| Filter, 1 micron absolute or NSF 53/58 cyst rated | Yes | Not all | No |
| Filter, 0.3 micron absolute or smaller | Yes | Yes | No |
| Reverse osmosis | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Chlorine bleach or iodine | Do not work well | Yes | Yes |
| Boiling | Yes | Yes | Yes |
CDC also notes that most portable water filters remove parasites but not viruses or bacteria, so read the pore size and rating, not the box headline. Clear water can still carry germs: CDC says drinking straight from a clear mountain stream is generally not safe.
Three portable designs compared
| Spec | Platypus QuickDraw 1L | Platypus GravityWorks | MSR Guardian |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Squeeze filter | Gravity filter | Pump purifier |
| Pore size | 0.2 micron | 0.2 micron | 0.02 micron |
| Viruses | No | No | Yes |
| Flow | Up to 3 L/min | Up to 1.75 L/min | 2.5 L/min |
| Filter life | 1,000 L | Up to 1,500 L | 10,000+ L |
| Weight | 3.3 oz system | 11.5 oz system | 1 lb 1 oz |
| Chemicals | No | No | No |
All three figures come from the makers' spec tables. The Platypus filters list removal of 99.9999% of bacteria and 99.9% of protozoa, including Giardia and Cryptosporidium. MSR says the Guardian meets NSF protocol P248 for viruses, bacteria, protozoa and sediment.
Squeeze, gravity or pump?
- Squeeze: the lightest option. Platypus says the QuickDraw system packs smaller than a rolled-up t-shirt and threads onto its own reservoir or bottles such as smartwater. You squeeze each liter by hand, which suits one person.
- Gravity: fill the dirty bag, hang it and let it drain through the filter. Platypus sells GravityWorks in 4.0 L and 6.0 L sizes for groups and camps, with a hose clamp to control the clean side.
- Pump: the Guardian pumps 2.5 liters per minute, and MSR says it self-cleans on every stroke, so there is no backflushing. It is the heaviest of the three, but it is the only one here rated for viruses.
How long a filter lasts, in household terms
A liter is about 0.264 gallons, so the makers' filter life figures work out to:
- QuickDraw: 1,000 L, about 264 gallons.
- GravityWorks: up to 1,500 L, about 396 gallons.
- Guardian: 10,000+ L, about 2,642 gallons.
Ready.gov plans for one gallon per person per day, for drinking and sanitation. For a household of four, 264 gallons covers about 66 days, 396 gallons about 99 days, and 2,642 gallons about 660 days. Treat these as the makers' maximum figures, and carry a spare cartridge for long use. The Guardian lists a cartridge replacement indicator; the Platypus filters do not.
Using a portable filter safely
- Filter before UV or chemicals. CDC says UV treatment does not work well in cloudy water and recommends filtering before UV or chemical disinfection.
- Disinfect if viruses are a concern. CDC lists unscented household chlorine bleach, iodine or chlorine dioxide tablets after filtering. It says people who are pregnant, have thyroid problems or are sensitive to iodine should avoid iodine-treated water, and no one should drink it for more than a few weeks at a time.
- Clean it as the maker says. Platypus lists backflushing for both of its filters; MSR's pump self-cleans.
- Know when to boil instead. CDC calls boiling the best way to kill germs: a rolling boil for 1 minute, or 3 minutes above 6,500 feet.
What to look for when you buy
Lightest: Platypus QuickDraw 1L Filter System
Best for: One person who wants the smallest, lightest filter for a pack or go bag
Platypus lists a 0.2 micron hollow fiber filter, up to 3 L per minute, 1,000 L of filter life and a 3.3 oz system that threads onto common bottles.
Watch out: Not rated for viruses or chemicals; disinfect after filtering when viruses are a concern.
See options on Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab)For groups: Platypus GravityWorks Water Filter System
Best for: Families and camps that want hands-free filtering in volume
Platypus lists a 0.2 micron hollow fiber filter, up to 1.75 L per minute without pumping, up to 1,500 L of filter life, 4.0 L or 6.0 L reservoirs and an 11.5 oz system.
Watch out: Needs somewhere to hang the dirty bag; not rated for viruses or chemicals.
See options on Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab)Virus protection: MSR Guardian Purifier
Best for: Travel or emergency kits where viruses may be in the water
MSR lists a 0.02 micron pore size, removal of viruses, bacteria and protozoa under NSF protocol P248, 2.5 L per minute, 10,000+ L of cartridge life and a self-cleaning pump.
Watch out: At 1 lb 1 oz it is the heaviest here, and it does not remove chemicals or toxins.
See options on Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab)Questions people ask
- Do portable water filters remove viruses?
- Most do not; CDC says a 0.3 micron or smaller filter removes bacteria and parasites but not viruses, so use a purifier or disinfect after filtering.
- What pore size should a portable water filter have?
- CDC says 0.3 micron absolute or smaller removes bacteria and parasites; the Platypus filters here list 0.2 micron and the MSR Guardian 0.02 micron.
- How long does a portable water filter last?
- The makers list 1,000 L for the QuickDraw, up to 1,500 L for GravityWorks and 10,000+ L for the Guardian, as maximum figures.
- Can a portable filter make any water safe?
- No; CDC says boiling or disinfecting cannot make water with chemicals, toxins or radioactive material safe, and these filters list no chemical removal.
Sources
- About Water Treatment Options When Hiking, Camping, or Traveling, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
- QuickDraw 1L Filter System, Platypus (Cascade Designs)
- GravityWorks Water Filter System, Platypus (Cascade Designs)
- Guardian Purifier, MSR (Cascade Designs)
- Build a Kit, Ready.gov