Garden seeds: open-pollinated if you want to save seed
We research products from makers' specs, manuals and safety agencies; we do not run hands-on tests. Links to Amazon may earn us a commission at no cost to you. How this works.
Quick answer
For a backyard food garden, buy open-pollinated or heirloom seed if you want to save seed and replant; UMN Extension says these set seed that grows plants very similar to the parent, while seed saved from hybrids does not. Almost all home garden vegetable seed is non-GMO anyway: FDA lists only a few GMO fresh crops, such as some potatoes, summer squash, apples and papayas. Store seeds dry and cool, ideally 32 to 41°F, in sealed glass jars.
Heirloom, open-pollinated and hybrid in plain terms
| Type | What UMN Extension says | Save seed? |
|---|---|---|
| Open-pollinated | Pollinated by the same variety, sets seed that grows into plants very similar to the parent | Yes |
| Heirloom | Open-pollinated varieties passed down through generations; open-pollinated can also include newer selections | Yes |
| Hybrid | A cross between two varieties, sometimes with outstanding vigor, disease resistance and productivity; costs more to produce | Seed is viable, but offspring are unpredictable |
UMN names examples: 'Brandywine', 'San Marzano' and 'Big Rainbow' tomatoes and 'California Wonder' peppers are open-pollinated; 'Big Boy', 'Beefmaster' and 'Early Girl' tomatoes are hybrids.
What non-GMO means on a seed packet
- Few GMO garden crops exist: FDA lists potatoes, summer squash, apples, papayas and pink pineapples as the few fresh produce items available in GMO varieties.
- The big GMO crops are farm crops: soybeans, corn, sugar beets, canola and cotton; FDA says GMO varieties made up 92% of corn planted in 2020, mostly for animal feed and ingredients.
- So the label adds little: a packet of heirloom tomato or bean seed was never going to be GMO. Look for open-pollinated, heirloom or hybrid, which tell you more about how the plant grows and whether you can save its seed.
- Non-GMO is not organic: organic is a separate certification; neither label says anything about germination or variety fit for your climate.
Best crops for saving your own seed
- Easiest: UMN lists tomatoes, peppers, beans and peas, which have self-pollinating flowers and seeds needing little or no treatment before storage.
- Harder: biennials like carrots and beets need two growing seasons to set seed.
- Cross-pollinators: corn and vine crops cross easily; UMN notes popcorn can pollinate sweet corn in a nearby garden on a windy day, and insects cross cucumbers, melons, squash, pumpkins and gourds.
- Pick parents carefully: save seed only from the most vigorous plants with the best-tasting fruit, and never from weak or off-type plants.
Harvesting seed, crop by crop
- Tomatoes: scoop seeds and gel into a jar with water, swirl twice a day, and after the mixture ferments and seeds sink, within about five days, rinse and dry on paper towels.
- Peppers: leave some fruit on the plant until fully ripe and wrinkling, then remove and dry the seeds.
- Beans and peas: let pods dry on the plant until seeds rattle, which UMN says can take a month past eating stage, then dry the pods indoors at least two weeks before shelling.
Storing seeds so they last
- Container: UMN recommends tightly sealed glass containers; individual paper packets can go inside one large jar.
- Temperature: 32 to 41°F is ideal, so a refrigerator works.
- Dry: add a small amount of silica gel desiccant, or one to two tablespoons of fresh powdered milk wrapped in tissue, which UMN says absorbs moisture for about six months.
- Label: write the variety and year on every packet so you plant the oldest first.
- Clean seed: UMN warns that tomato bacterial canker can arrive on infected seed; buy from a reputable supplier and save seed only from healthy plants.
A seed supply for food security
A seed collection is a long-term food plan, not a short-term emergency ration: it takes a season to produce food. Start with crops your family eats, in a mix of cool-season greens and roots and warm-season tomatoes, peppers and squash. Plant some every year so you learn your soil and keep fresh seed in rotation. For shelf-stable food while the garden grows, see our freeze dried food and mylar bags guides.
What to look for when you buy
Starter garden: Survival Garden Seeds 30-Packet Family Home Garden Kit
Best for: A first or family-sized food garden
The maker lists 30 packets and over 18,500 heirloom, non-GMO, open-pollinated seeds covering greens, roots, tomatoes, peppers, squash, herbs and flowers, with planting and seed-saving notes on each packet.
Watch out: Check which varieties suit your growing season and region before planting.
See options on Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab)Larger seed bank: Survival Garden Seeds Farmer's 100-Packet Collection
Best for: Bigger gardens and building a seed supply over several seasons
The maker lists 100 heirloom, non-GMO, open-pollinated packets including annual, biennial and perennial crops, seed-saving information and a protective storage bucket.
Watch out: More varieties than most gardens can plant at once; store the extras cool, dry and sealed.
See options on Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab)Keep stored seed dry: silica gel desiccant packets
Best for: Jars of saved or spare seed
UMN Extension recommends a small amount of silica gel in each sealed glass container to absorb moisture and keep seeds dry.
Watch out: Keep desiccant packets away from children and pets; replace them when saturated.
See options on Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab)Questions people ask
- What are the best garden seeds for a survival garden?
- Open-pollinated or heirloom seed of crops you eat, so you can save seed; UMN lists tomatoes, peppers, beans and peas as the easiest to save.
- Are non-GMO vegetable seeds different from regular seeds?
- Usually not; FDA lists only a few GMO fresh crops, such as some potatoes, summer squash, apples and papayas.
- Can I save seeds from hybrid vegetables?
- They produce viable seed, but UMN says the plants will not match the hybrid parent.
- How should I store garden seeds?
- In sealed glass jars, dry and cool; UMN says 32 to 41°F is ideal, with silica gel to absorb moisture.
Sources
- Saving vegetable seeds, University of Minnesota Extension
- GMO Crops, Animal Food, and Beyond, U.S. Food and Drug Administration
- 30-Packet Family Home Garden Seed Kit, Survival Garden Seeds
- Farmer's Seed Collection, 100 Heirloom Seed Packets, Survival Garden Seeds